Never mind. I think I just figured it out. This is what I did differently with that expression:
=DCount("[ID]","tblWeeklyNumbers"," [data_store] = 'INS' and [created] <= Forms!frmDateRange_forWeeklyStatRpt![txtend] And ([status] = 'active' or [status] like '*Pending*' or [status] = 'open' or...