Duh, thanks.
Although, now the entire result is a repeated value. For example, a rating of 2.5 is appearing as
êê.óóóóóóóóóóó (actual wingding characters) Formula is:
=String(Fix([OVERALL_RATING_NBR]),"ê") & "." & String(Val(Mid([OVERALL_RATING_NBR],InStr(1,[OVERALL_RATING_NBR],".")+1)),"ó")