Database Setup: Use Access or Excel

matpoh

New member
Local time
Today, 13:15
Joined
Aug 30, 2006
Messages
4
I have just begun learning MS Access and have some information already in an excel spreadsheet that is getting too big and I am trying to decide if converting the whole thing would be beneficial or jsut a waste of time.

The issue is the current excel file is a workbook of about 150 separate worksheets that are all hyperlinked to each other. It does everything I want, but I feel like it is getting to big and cumbersome and really all I want is to add one sheet/record and have all the totals/averages/"reports" update themselves. That is why I think Access might be better. Currently it takes a good minute to update the file when saving. The Excel file is about 13mb.

The data is basically all times from a mens & womens cross country team. I have one form I take to each meet and record mile splits, places, final time, etc. Then I return and currently put those times into excel. I have 4 years of data for each runner. I also have 10 years of team data that needs to be able to be recalled usefully. My spreadsheet also looks through all past meets and keeps a list of the top 50 times for both men and women. And compiles every practice/workouts for the past 8 years, etc. Plus a lot of other sheets/forms/reports/.

I started a database and have one table for Athletes, one for MeetEntry. I also created a report for the meet entry to send to media. I then started working with relationships between different tables and became overwhelmed with how to best set up the entire database. I came up with a list of things and organized them into what I thought would be best suited for Tables vs. Forms vs. Queries vs. Reports. With the limited info, any ideas on setup would be appreciated. Maybe I just leave it in Excel and forget Access.

I think with the complexity, this is much better suited to my needs but it may be just a bit over my head. I do not know an VB so that is also an issue.

Suggestions
 
Accss is immensely powerful and is a quantum step from Excel.
You must understand Normalisation, relationships Primary keys, foreign keys.

All of these will get you by the short and curlies if you do not do your best to get to grips with them.

So my advice. Access is the thing, however be prepared for frustration, confusion, aggravation and despair, not necessarily in that order. Fight your way through these and the glase will lift from your eyes to reveal a world in which you can do anything (logical that is) much to the amazement of others. Be prepared for people to believe you are practising a black art.

If you can hack Excel across 150 sheets then you can get to grips with Access.

hey join the mad buggers on this forum and stand out in a crowd. (muttering sql, vba and otehr words)

Len
 
Terry pratchett Fan

Len Boorman said:
(muttering sql, vba and otehr words)

I didn't realize you were a Terry pratchett Fan --- (Igor) --- Len!
 
Uncle Gizmo said:
I didn't realize you were a Terry pratchett Fan --- (Igor) --- Len!


the famous "fantasy author" eh

Been told I live in a fantasy world before but never so politely. :D :D :D

Must confess did have to "google". Led a sheltered life

L
 
Len Boorman said:
the famous "fantasy author" eh

Been told I live in a fantasy world before but never so politely. :D :D :D

Must confess did have to "google". Led a sheltered life

L

Terry pratchett is also very funny! So if you like fantasy, magic, political satire, comical witty, subtle writing then I suggest you grab a Terry pratchett book when you see one. Alternatively I would only be too pleased to send you one in the post, just say...

cheers Tony.
 
Thanks for the reply. I think I am on the right track. I likely will have to sit down and sketch out how I want everything to relate to each other.

I did set up an athletes table and in the meet entry table, I have it look at the athletes names as a drop down menu to choose runners for the meet entry.

I think from past FileMaker experience, they called it a container field. Is there something similar in Access or do you just make a normal field and have it point to a different table?
 
matpoh said:
I think from past FileMaker experience, they called it a container field. Is there something similar in Access or do you just make a normal field and have it point to a different table?

Combo box is commonly used

L
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom