Both tables have the exact same number of rows.... 96406
I wasn't able to set a primary key... Access did say there were duplicates. Hmmm, maybe I do need multiple joins.... I'll take another look at the data. Thank you so much for your help.

Since you asked, here's the SQL code for the join:
INSERT INTO DALPPROP ( ACCT_NUM, REACCT, REGION, ROUTE, BLDG_CLASS, TYPE_FIRM, STATUS, REND_CURR, REND_PAST, REFUSED, REF_PAST, POC, ST_NUM1, ST_DIR1, ST_NAME1, ST_SUFFIX, ST_HALFNUM, SUITE, CITY, TAXP_NAME1, PHONE, EST_DATE, TAX_CONSUL, BLDG_AREA, [CURRENT], PAST, SCITY, SSCHOOL, EFF_AGE, J1, SP1, HOSPITAL, COLLEGE, APPDATE, WKINV, WKMATL, WKSUPPLIES, WKCONSGD, WKFURN_FIX, WKMACHEQ, WKCOMPUTER, WKVEHICLE, WKLEASEDEQ, WKAIRCRAFT, WKLEASEHOL, WKMISC, PREVINVVAL, NAME_BUS, MAPSCO )
SELECT DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.ACCOUNT_NUM, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.GIS_NUM, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.REGION, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.ROUTE, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.PROPERTY_CLASS, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.BUSINESS_TYPE, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.ACCT_STATUS, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.RENDERED_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.RENDERED_PRIOR, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.REFUSED_ENTRY_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.REFUSED_ENTRY_PRIOR, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.PERSON_CONTACTED, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.STREET_NUM, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.STREET_DIR, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.STREET_NAME, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.STREET_SUFFIX, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.STREET_HALF_NUM, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.SUITE_NUMBER, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.CITY, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.OWNER_NAME, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.OWNER_PHONE, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.ESTABLISHED_DT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.TAX_CONSULTANT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.TOT_SF, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.TOT_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.TOT_VAL_PRIOR, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.CITY_TAXABLE_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.ISD_TAXABLE_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.EFFECTIVE_AGE, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.CNTY_JURIS, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.SPDS_JURIS, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.HOSP_JURIS, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.COLL_JURIS, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.APPRAISAL_DT_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.INVENTORY_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.RAW_MATERIALS_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.SUPPLIES_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.CONS_GOODS_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.FURN_FIX_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.MACH_EQUIP_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.COMPUTERS_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.VEHICLES_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.LEASE_EQUIP_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.AIRCRAFT_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.LH_IMPROVE_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.MISC_VAL_CURRENT, DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.INVENTORY_VAL_PRIOR, BPP_AccountInfo_07252012.BIZ_NAME, BPP_AccountInfo_07252012.MAPSCO
FROM DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011 INNER JOIN BPP_AccountInfo_07252012 ON (DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.APPRAISAL_YR = BPP_AccountInfo_07252012.APPRAISAL_YR) AND (DCAD2011_BPP_DETAIL_CERTIFIED_07252011.ACCOUNT_NUM = BPP_AccountInfo_07252012.ACCOUNT_NUM);