Review my DB

[Acidburn]

lovley but ive shown it to my end user and he preferes the first one. Is the fist one so bad?

 

[Mile-O]

Is the fist one so bad?

I'll let others answer that for you. As I see it, it doesn't achieve the First Normal Form (1NF) of database normalisation. A sturdy database will, at least, achieve Third Normal Form (3NF).

 

[Acidburn]

was yours a 3rd? as i need to achieve a 1st and what does a 1st look like?

 

[Mile-O]

Database Normalization Basics

Understanding Relational Database Design - get the download here