Well said Stopher. Although I completely agree with Bob's view that watercooler posts should not be counted as any great feat (being a bit of a gab myself),
Spot on. If my memory is working correctly then I think Bob Larson had a pile of them with a built in image.
What about responses to questions where the response is incorrect or less than desirable.....should they be deducted from the post count.
I would think for the people who have a vested interest in the forum a bigger issue than where posts are made would be to seek the answer as to why the vast majority of members never get past about 10 posts in total.
Drop the post count entirely. Don't bother displaying it on the thread at all. (I know this is possible as this is indeed done on another vBulletin forum)
People are funny; give them some kind of numbers and it becomes gold to them. Take it away then it's just that. Numbers.
You know, I actually like that. This always means we'll have to know each other by name, not by post count, and this insulates new people from targeting old codgers for that blue special PM "HELP ME!"....